Final Girls Book Club

Monthly horror picks for the mortally curious.

Current month: August 2025

Novels

Choose one full‑length pick for the month.

August’s Winner
Novel
Between Two Fires
Christopher Buehlman (2012)
~430 pages Debut novel: No Avg rating: 4.2★
Theme
Apocalyptic Horror
CW Extreme

Vibe: Medieval Black Death horror where a disgraced knight and a mysterious girl walk straight into a war between Heaven and Hell.

As the plague ravages 14th-century France, a disillusioned knight named Thomas falls in with Delphine, a peasant girl who claims to speak with angels — right as Lucifer makes his move to finish a war against Heaven. The novel pairs historical grimness (plague, famine, religious violence) with outright apocalyptic horror as the two travel toward Avignon.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Sexual assault and threat of sexual assault involving minors, child endangerment, torture, extreme body horror, religious violence, antisemitism, anti-gay bigotry, alcohol addiction.

Novel
When the Wolf Comes Home
Nat Cassidy (2025)
~300 pages Debut novel: No Avg rating: 4.1★
Theme
Werewolf Horror
CW Extreme

Vibe: A blood-soaked, fast-moving werewolf chase novel about a woman, a runaway kid, and the thing hunting them both.

Jessa's rough night at the diner turns into something far worse when she finds a terrified runaway boy outside, followed almost immediately by a violent encounter with his father. As they flee together, Jessa slowly realizes the boy's fear itself is manifesting into monstrous, bloody reality behind them.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Graphic violence and gore, child endangerment, abuse, alcoholism, parent death, self-harm, kidnapping, body horror.

Novel
The Troop
Nick Cutter (2014)
~380 pages Debut novel: No Avg rating: 4.0★
Theme
Survival Horror
CW Extreme

Vibe: Lord of the Flies with parasitic worms and no safety rails.

A scoutmaster takes a small troop of boys on a routine camping trip to a remote Canadian island, only to have a starving, infected stranger stagger into camp. Once the parasite spreads, the story turns into a brutally graphic survival nightmare as hunger, infection, and cruelty strip away any veneer of civility.

Origin: Canada

Content warnings: Extreme gore, body horror, animal death, starvation, bullying, child endangerment.

Novel
The Exorcist
William Peter Blatty (1971)
~380 pages Debut novel: No Avg rating: 4.2★
Part of a series
The Exorcist
  1. The Exorcist
  2. Legion
Theme
Possession
CW Extreme

Vibe: The classic possession novel that defined the genre — a mother's search for answers as her daughter's body and mind are taken over by something ancient.

When young Regan begins exhibiting terrifying, inexplicable behavior, her mother exhausts every medical explanation before turning to the Church for help. Two priests are drawn into a brutal, escalating exorcism that tests their faith as much as it endangers their lives, in the novel that inspired the landmark film.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Graphic violence against a child, blasphemy/religious desecration, disturbing sexual content, profanity, body horror.

Short works & novellas

Pick one shorter nightmare to pair with the novel.

August’s Winner
Short story
A Short Stay in Hell
Steven L. Peck (2011)
~110 pages Debut book: No Avg rating: 4.1★
Theme
Existential Horror
CW Heavy

Vibe: A devout Mormon geologist dies and wakes up in a Hell that punishes him with an incomprehensibly vast library instead of fire.

Soren Johansson dies expecting to reunite with his family in the afterlife, and instead finds himself condemned by an unfamiliar god to a Hell built as an endless library. His only way out is to find the one book, among an effectively infinite number, that tells the true story of his life — a existential, slow-building horror about eternity and futility rather than gore.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Existential dread, themes of eternal suffering and futility, brief violence, death of loved ones (referenced).

Short story
Cabal
Clive Barker (1988)
~250 pages Debut book: No Avg rating: 3.9★
Theme
Monster Horror
CW Extreme

Vibe: A monstrous found-family horror novella where the real killers turn out to be entirely human.

Boone, convinced by his manipulative therapist that he's a serial killer, turns himself in and learns of Midian, a hidden refuge for shape-shifting creatures called the Nightbreed. As Boone is drawn into Midian and its inhabitants, the story flips expectations about who the real monsters are, building to a bloody confrontation with the humans hunting the Nightbreed down.

Origin: United Kingdom

Content warnings: Graphic violence and gore, body horror, mass murder, psychological manipulation, mob violence.

Short story
Carmilla
Sheridan Le Fanu (1872)
~110 pages Debut book: No Avg rating: 3.9★
Theme
Vampire Horror
CW Heavy

Vibe: The original lesbian vampire novella, predating Dracula by decades and dripping with gothic sexual tension.

Isolated in a remote Austrian castle, Laura is captivated by Carmilla, a strange and beautiful young guest who arrives after a carriage accident. As their intense friendship deepens, Laura grows increasingly ill and haunted by nightmares, slowly realizing what — and who — Carmilla really is.

Origin: Ireland

Content warnings: Vampirism/blood-drinking, death, illness, predatory undertones, period-typical treatment of female sexuality and class.