Final Girls Book Club

Monthly horror picks for the mortally curious.

Theme Nautical Horror

Current month: November 2025

Novels

Choose one full‑length pick for the month.

November’s Winner
Novel
Into the Drowning Deep
Mira Grant (2017)
~440 pages Debut novel: No Avg rating: 4.0★
Part of a series
Rolling in the Deep
  1. Rolling in the Deep
  2. Into the Drowning Deep
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Extreme

Vibe: A big, gory monster-movie novel about the crew sent to find out what really killed the ship that vanished making a mermaid mockumentary.

Seven years after the Atargatis disappeared while filming a fake documentary about mermaids, a new, better-funded expedition sets out to find out what actually happened — bringing scientists, hunters, and a woman searching for her lost sister. What they find in the Mariana Trench is very real, very hungry, and not remotely like the CGI mermaids from the original broadcast.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Extreme gore and body horror, multiple graphic deaths, gun violence, animal death, an abusive ex-partner subplot.

Novel
The Fisherman
John Langan (2016)
~270 pages Debut novel: No Avg rating: 3.9★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Extreme

Vibe: A cosmic-horror novel about grief and fishing that turns into something much stranger once it reaches the reservoir.

Two widowers, Abe and Dan, bond over fishing trips as a way of coping with the deaths of their wives, eventually venturing to a mysterious stream rumored among locals to be dangerous. An embedded tale about the historic construction of the Ashokan Reservoir unspools alongside their story, both converging on something ancient and cosmic beneath the water.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Graphic violence, child death, sexual content, emotional abuse, suicide, substance use, mental illness, racism (period-typical).

Novel
Whalefall
Daniel Kraus (2023)
~340 pages Debut novel: No Avg rating: 4.2★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Heavy

Vibe: A single-location survival thriller about a teenage diver who gets swallowed whole by a sperm whale.

Diving alone to recover his late father's remains, seventeen-year-old Jay is suddenly swallowed by a sperm whale, with limited air and no way out. Trapped inside the whale's stomach, he relives his complicated relationship with his father while racing to find a way to survive.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Graphic bodily/visceral imagery, death of a parent, near-death experience, claustrophobia/confinement.

Novel
Our Wives Under the Sea
Julia Armfield (2022)
~240 pages Debut novel: No Avg rating: 3.7★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Extreme

Vibe: A quiet, literary body-horror novel about a woman whose wife came back from a deep-sea expedition changed.

Miri is relieved when her wife Leah finally returns from a submarine expedition that went catastrophically wrong, stranding the crew on the ocean floor for months. But Leah isn't quite the same person who left, and Miri slowly realizes something from the deep came back with her.

Origin: United Kingdom

Content warnings: Graphic body horror, grief, terminal illness, suicide, confinement, loss of a parent, disordered eating themes.

Short works & novellas

Pick one shorter nightmare to pair with the novel.

Short story
The Upper Berth
F. Marion Crawford (1886)
~30 pages Debut book: No Avg rating: 4.0★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Heavy

Vibe: A classic maritime ghost story about a cursed berth on an ocean liner that no passenger survives sleeping in.

A seasoned traveler books passage on a transatlantic steamer and is assigned an upper berth in a cabin with an inexplicably damp, cold porthole that won't stay shut. As previous occupants' fates come to light, the story builds toward a confrontation with whatever haunts the cabin at sea.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Death, drowning (implied), supernatural threat/confrontation, period-typical seafaring peril.

Short story
The Temple
H.P. Lovecraft (1925)
~20 pages Debut book: No Avg rating: 3.7★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Extreme

Vibe: A doomed WWI U-boat crew's descent into madness after finding a sunken, ancient temple beneath the sea.

Told as the recovered log of a German U-boat commander, the story follows his crew's unraveling sanity after they sink a ship and begin experiencing inexplicable, escalating horrors at sea. As the crew dwindles, the captain becomes fixated on a strange submerged temple that seems to be calling to him.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Violence, executions/summary killings, madness/psychological breakdown, wartime brutality.

Short story
A Tropical Horror
William Hope Hodgson (1905)
~10 pages Debut book: No Avg rating: 3.8★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Extreme

Vibe: A short, brutal creature-feature about a monstrous eel-like sea beast that boards a ship and picks off the crew one by one.

A young ship's apprentice narrates the aftermath of a giant sea creature climbing aboard his vessel in the night, killing and devouring the crew over several harrowing days. The survivors' increasingly desperate attempts to fight back build to a violent final confrontation with the thing.

Origin: United Kingdom

Content warnings: Graphic violence, body horror, character deaths, sustained dread/threat.

November’s Winner
Short story
The Shadow over Innsmouth
H.P. Lovecraft (1931)
~70 pages Debut book: No Avg rating: 4.1★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Heavy

Vibe: The foundational Deep Ones novella — a decaying New England seaport hiding an ancient bargain with something amphibious.

A young antiquarian's research trip leads him to Innsmouth, a decrepit fishing town whose residents have a strange, fish-like appearance and a deep-seated hostility to outsiders. Trapped overnight, he uncovers the town's generations-old pact with an undersea civilization — and what that means for his own bloodline.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Xenophobic and racially-coded "degeneration" themes (a well-documented issue in Lovecraft's work), body horror, mob violence, pursuit/chase horror.