Final Girls Book Club

Monthly horror picks for the mortally curious.

Theme Witches & Witchcraft

Current month: July 2026

Novels

Choose one full‑length pick for the month.

July’s Winner
Novel
Slewfoot: A Tale of Bewitchery
Brom (2021)
~320 pages Debut novel: No Avg rating: 4.3★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Extreme

Vibe: A lush, illustrated Puritan-era horror novel about a widow accused of witchcraft who forms a bargain with an ancient forest spirit.

In 1666 colonial Connecticut, newly widowed Abitha is targeted by her suspicious, hostile community right as a strange, ancient being awakens in the nearby woods and offers her his power. As Abitha embraces witchcraft to survive, the story builds toward a bloody reckoning between the Puritan settlement and the older, wilder forces it displaced.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Graphic violence, sexual assault, religious persecution, animal death, torture, colonial-era brutality.

Novel
Maggie's Grave
David Sodergren (2021)
~350 pages Debut novel: No Avg rating: 4.2★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Extreme

Vibe: A gleefully savage splatter-horror novel about a wronged 'witch' resurrected for bloody revenge on the village that killed her.

Centuries after being murdered by a Scottish village as a witch, Maggie Wall's grave is disturbed, resurrecting her and her fury at the descendants of those responsible. The novel turns into an over-the-top, deliriously violent revenge rampage through the modern-day town.

Origin: United Kingdom

Content warnings: Extreme graphic violence and gore, sexual assault, torture, animal death, dismemberment.

Novel
The Year of the Witching
Alexis Henderson (2020)
~360 pages Debut novel: Yes Avg rating: 3.9★
Part of a series
Bethel
  1. The Year of the Witching
  2. The Dawn of the Coven
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Extreme

Vibe: A dark, feminist gothic about a rigid theocratic settlement, the witches haunting its cursed woods, and a girl who starts asking why.

In the strict, patriarchal settlement of Bethel, Immanuelle stumbles into the cursed forest bordering town and discovers her dead mother's journal, hinting at forbidden secrets. As she's drawn deeper into the witches' power and the truth behind Bethel's founding, she becomes a threat to the church that rules it.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Graphic violence, religious abuse and extremism, sexual assault, self-harm, body horror, misogyny.

Novel
Red Rabbit
Alex Grecian (2022)
~430 pages Debut novel: No Avg rating: 3.6★
Part of a series
Red Rabbit
  1. Red Rabbit
  2. Rose of Jericho
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Extreme

Vibe: A blood-soaked Weird Western about a witch-hunting party crossing a Kansas plagued by supernatural horrors.

A witch and a gunslinger reluctantly team up with a ragtag group crossing the post-Civil War Kansas plains, hunting a powerful and monstrous witch responsible for a string of horrors. Along the way the group encounters a string of supernatural threats that turn the journey into a violent, episodic nightmare.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Graphic violence and gore, body horror, animal death, racism (period-typical), sexual content.

Short works & novellas

Pick one shorter nightmare to pair with the novel.

Short story
The White People
Arthur Machen (1904)
~40 pages Debut book: No Avg rating: 3.8★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Heavy

Vibe: A hallucinatory, dreamlike weird-fiction classic told through a young girl's increasingly disturbing secret diary of witchcraft and hidden rites.

Framed by a philosophical discussion of true evil, the story presents the diary of a young girl who is gradually initiated into a secret, ancient tradition of witchcraft and folklore by her nurse. The diary's dreamlike, fragmented prose builds an atmosphere of creeping wrongness rather than explicit horror.

Origin: United Kingdom

Content warnings: Disturbing/ambiguous themes of ritual abuse, child endangerment, unsettling occult imagery.

July’s Winner
Short story
This Town Doesn't Exist on Any Map
Tobias Wade (2019)
~30 pages Debut book: No Avg rating: N/A
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Extreme

Vibe: A viral creepypasta-style story about a driver who stumbles into an impossible small town that shouldn't exist — and can't seem to leave.

A late-night wrong turn leads the narrator into a strange small town with no cell signal, no visible way out, and an escalating sense that something is deeply, deliberately wrong with its residents. As the narrator tries to find a way back to the highway, the town's true, witchcraft-tinged nature closes in.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Psychological horror, disturbing imagery, implied violence, isolation/entrapment themes.

Short story
Dreams in the Witch House
H.P. Lovecraft (1933)
~40 pages Debut book: No Avg rating: 3.6★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Extreme

Vibe: A cosmic-horror take on witchcraft — a student's rented room in a crooked old house opens onto other dimensions, and a witch who never really left.

A mathematics student rents a room in a notoriously crooked old Arkham house once inhabited by an executed witch, drawn by the building's strange non-Euclidean geometry. His studies of the room's angles begin to open dream-visions of other realities, and of the witch and her monstrous familiar, still very much active.

Origin: United States

Content warnings: Child sacrifice, graphic violence, body horror, disturbing occult imagery, period-typical racism.

Short story
Viy
Nikolai Gogol (1835)
~40 pages Debut book: No Avg rating: 3.9★
Theme fit
5 / 5
CW Heavy

Vibe: A Ukrainian folk-horror classic about a seminary student trapped reciting prayers over the corpse of a witch for three increasingly terrifying nights.

After a fatal encounter with an old woman who turns out to be a witch, seminarian Khoma Brutus is ordered to keep vigil over her body in a remote church for three nights. Each night grows more nightmarish as the witch's corpse and the demonic forces she commands close in around him.

Origin: Ukraine

Content warnings: Death, supernatural/demonic threat, disturbing imagery, religious horror.